(Picture from yasminthefilmmaker.blogspot.com – potential spoilers ahead)
When director Yasmin Ahmad chose to release her film in Singapore first, the Malaysian press criticised her as being “disloyal”. But with rampant piracy and censorship issues plaguing the Malaysian film industry, one can probably fathom why she had to make the decision. Dubbed as being the film that “Malaysia may never get to see”, the film opened with little fanfare in Singapore yesterday.
We caught the third screening of Muallaf at an almost full 70-odd seated Cathay Picturehouse. The diverse crowd made up of mixed ethnicity consisted of Malays, Chinese and Sikhs, some probably even coming all the way from Malaysia to see the film. The seats behind me were occupied by a family with two kids who murmured questions to their parents at various parts of the show. Being my second Yasmin Ahmad film after the critically acclaimed Sepet, my expectations of the film were, for sure, high.
Muallaf revolves around the secret lives of two sisters from a Datuk family, who ran away from their father. The Datuk then remarried, and together with their tyrant stepmother, makes life difficult for them. The two English-sprouting sisters, being extremely worldly and passionate in education, but yet retaining their Islamic followings faithfully, are symbols of the perfect mix between modernity and traditionalism. Looking at this brief summary, it pretty much sums up the plot for 3/4 of the film, and we start to wonder which part of “Muallaf”, which means “The Convert”, is being played out in the film.
Although the entire story mainly focuses on the two sisters, the “convert” actually refers to Brian, their 30-odd year old schoolteacher who gave up his Catholic faith because of issues with his father. His chance encounter with the two sisters in the school sees him getting involved in their lives, and eventually, Brian returns to his faith, and reconciles with his mum.
With many issues brought up for discussion in the entire film, I was impressed with how well the characters were developed at the initial part of the story. The seamless exposition about how their personalities turned out to be due to the impact of various events in their lives were extremely well thought out, and what I liked most was the issues the filmmaker wished to highlight weaved beautifully into the plot. There isn’t a boring scene, and the many tongue-in-cheek moments in the film kept the audiences well-entertained.
The earlier part of the film explores the struggles of the two sisters, the elder one who has to work in the pub in order to support two mouths, and the younger one having accused of being a rebel in school. It is because she utters chains of numbers when she’s faced with difficult situations, which is fuelled by the incompetent teachers whom mistakes she tries to correct. Next, we see a scene of Datuk in the nightclub with the company of several scantily clad Chinese girls. The education system also got battered in the film. It’s somewhat like the Malaysian version of Just Follow Law, less of the humour but more of a serious jibe at the politics and governance of Malaysia. One can laugh off the issues in Just Follow Law, but those in Muallaf were more of causes of worry at the state of affairs in the country. For sure, it was no wonder the film sent censors hopping mad.
The later part of the film saw a rather sudden shift in focus of the story to Brian, when he gets intrigued (and impressed) with the girls’ intricate interest in religion. He falls in love with the elder sister, and starts doing things for them when he understands their difficulties. Juggling between the girls and his mum, he is being forced to make a decision between the two parties. At this point of time, the story plunges into a somewhat uncertain direction, and as sudden as it could be, I ceased to feel for the film. Attempts to bring out slapstick humour at the taekwondo lesson scene when the younger sister’s friend saw her dad abusing her mum, and then took her dad down, was a tad too corny in my opinion. Similarly, the drive to play up the female-deprived personality of Brian went a little too far, also.
Putting aside some of these cheesy scenes, occasional unconvincing acting by some of the supporting cast and camera jerks which somehow affected the overall production quality of the film, the exploration of the characters, together with witty lines and excellent casting, the bringing up of a potentially controversial taboo topic of religion to be discussed in a largely conservative Malaysia seems to send a reminder to the country – to progress, or to be left behind. As for Director Yasmin Ahmad’s response to calls of being “disloyal” in Malaysia, she retorts: “I’m not disloyal, my dear fellow Malaysians. I’m just a victim of circumstance.”
Muallaf is now screening at the Picturehouse.
You can visit Yasmin Ahmad’s blog @ http://yasminthefilmmaker.blogspot.com